Catholicism Is NOT a Philosophy… Why Do We Teach It as One?


Is thinking the same as Faith?
Is thinking the same as Faith?

Enter most CCD classes and what do you see. Heads bobbing, boredom, abstract ideas, memorizing the Ten Commandments, lists of Old Testament figures, and a tons of don’ts.

But what is our faith? A living relationship with Jesus Christ! Pope Benedict has insisted on this time and time again.

Jesus did not say “follow my teaching” like Buddha, Socrates, or other philosophers. He said “follow me!”

If someone is love with Jesus they will avoid sin, they will learn about the Old Testament, and they will be able to repeat the Ten Commandments. However, love drives them to that rather than another boring class that seems no different from History or English except that the teacher lacks professional training.

If a young man tells you he thinks a girl is pretty and would like to know her, what do you do? Tell him to talk to her. Or maybe set up a “chance” meeting. You don’t tell him to go and study her family tree, memorize the rules in her house and her favorite band and then go meet her. If he falls in love with her, he will remember those other things, but with half the effort. Because those things are about the one he loves, love smooths the path. I doubt there is a loving husband who can’t name his wife’s parents and siblings. I doubt many wives don’t know their husbands’ favorite food and music.

We cannot keep religious education as something external – like Geography or Math. The goal is that this particular boy experiences Christ and falls in love with him. Few fall in love studying about their beloved. More fall in love spending time with their beloved, speaking with them, or serving with them.

So that teens fall in love with Christ, wouldn’t it be better to begin with adoration, with the rosary, or with service projects. Once the flame of love is enkindled, then we talk Jesus’ relatives and everything else. Learning should then come quick.

Liked it? Take a second to support Fr. Matthew P. Schneider, LC on Patreon!
Become a patron at Patreon!


  1. Very true. It does somehow tie in with what Pope Francis mentioned in one of his earlier interventions about everyone being in a search for “truth, goodness and beauty” – adolescents start that quest, some become old men and women and never quite grasp it – so it is always positive when an effort is made to minister to this quintessential instinct to experience Christ’s love… it certainly makes teaching easier, and learning all the more purposeful.
    Father Barron on his Youtube channel had a rather enlightening commentary too on the subject on how to approach it the other way around, beauty first, then goodness, then truth – which we thought particularly related to what we do (embroidering coat of arms – which seems silly to some, but there is a reasoning behind it) and thought you might enjoy it too if it has not come to your attention before.
    In either case, best of luck in your journey to the priesthood, your youth ministry goals, and this blog too. Happy Eastertide from us at KlaveCentesca.
    PS Thanks for the follow.

Add your voice to the discussion